WHAT A COMPLETE KNOBHEAD BENNETT IS

 Re: A Kate's “Oops… I Think I’ve Just Confessed” Moment

  Tony Bennett on Wed Jun 29, 2011 6:47 pm

Ringo wrote:Two points Tony

Tony Bennett wrote:1. To say that Tanner did not ID Robert Murat from the police van would be tantamount to asserting that Goncalo Amaral invented virtually the whole of that chapter. Amaral like the rest of us mortals makes mistakes and doesn't get everything right, but it is a very serious charge to say that he invented the whole scenario. Had he completely made this up, he would surely have been challenged by now

I am not asserting that he made up the whole scenario of the sighting from the van as that is verified by what JT says. However Amaral was not there, and I am asserting that he did get it wrong about her positively ID'ing Murat, yes.

4) she was not included in the face-to-face confrontation with Murat that the three others took part in
Because the simple issue was whether these three had in fact seen Murat hanging around the Ocean Club on the late evening of 3 May. Tanner never said she had seen Murat there. She merely said: 'I'm sure that's the bloke I saw carrying a child at about 9.15pm on 3 May'

Then why did Amaral claim in an interview last year that she WAS at the face-to-face confrontation with Murat, contradicting what he wrote in his book?

REPLY:

Point 1: As I understand it there is no evidence whatsoever that he did get it wrong, i.e. you are making an assertion based on no evidence. All you are syaing, without any evidential basis, is: 'He might have got it wrong'

Point 2. OK, I've not seen this interview. Assuming (a) that it says exactly what you say its says and (b) that there has been an accurate translation of what he said, then it looks to me most like a simple error of recollection. No-one else that I am aware of (not the Tapas Three, not Murat) has said that Tanner was also in 

that confrontation, so it sounds like a simple slip




NO BENNETT, YOU DO NOT PUT A SIMPLE ERROR OF RECOLLECTION INTO A BOOK THAT ATTACKS PARENTS. IT IS NOT A SIMPLE SLIP , IT IS AN OUTRIGHT LIE BY AMARAL AND ONE THAT SHOWS WHAT A LIAR HE IS. IT ALSO SHOWS HOW MUCH YOU HAVE RELIED ON LIES FROM THE FAT USELESS DEFECTIVE AS WELL